The Song He Tried to Kill
Have you ever heard a song so perfect, so utterly heartbreaking, that you can’t imagine it ever not existing? For me, that’s “He Stopped Loving Her Today” by the one and only George Jones. But what if I told you that the man who sang it, the legendary Possum himself, absolutely despised it?
It’s a wild story, but it’s true. When producer Billy Sherrill first brought the song to George, he was at the absolute lowest point in his life. He was battling his demons, and the last thing he wanted to sing was what he called a “morbid” and “depressing” tune about a man who only stops loving a woman when he dies. He fought Sherrill tooth and nail, refusing to record it.
But Billy Sherrill saw something George couldn’t. He saw a masterpiece hiding in the madness. He knew this song was special, and he wasn’t giving up.
So, over a series of chaotic, alcohol-fueled recording sessions, Sherrill came up with a clever plan. He knew he couldn’t get a full performance out of Jones, so he did the next best thing: he tricked him. He patiently worked with George, getting him to sing the verses line by painful line, often when Jones was barely aware of what he was doing. Can you even imagine the patience that must have taken?
Later, like a master craftsman, Sherrill painstakingly stitched all those fragmented, agonizing takes together. He edited the slurred words, pieced together the pained vocals, and built a seamless, epic story of heartbreak from the wreckage. It was a producer’s ultimate gamble.
The result? The song that George Jones tried to kill became the song that saved him. “He Stopped Loving Her Today” soared to number one, revived his career, and is now widely considered the single greatest country song in history. It’s a powerful, almost unbelievable testament to how immortal art can be pulled from the deepest depths of self-destruction, all thanks to a friend who refused to let a legend give up on his own masterpiece.